1up Clan Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Casper on May 09, 2010, 03:55:13 PM

Title: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 09, 2010, 03:55:13 PM
So first of all, i need to say this. please, nobody get angry or offensive in how they present their views. Dont try to make anyone mad, because you will just look like a jerk. Ive always been interested in this kind of thing, and what people believe, I personally believe in existiential nihilism, the belief that we are just another anomaly in the universe, and that human life is meaningless. However, most people believe different things. Post your views or arguments, because im very curious in what all of you believe  :D

Remember, i dont want this topic closed down. BE POLITE!!!! lol
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: bearcat on May 09, 2010, 05:13:51 PM
I believe in the Judeo-Christian God, I believe Jesus was who he said he was. I believe in a real heaven and hell. I believe the devil and his angels are still active in the world. I believe through my own actions determine whether I will end up in heaven or hell, with the grace of God.

Those who know your name will trust in you,
for you, LORD, have never forsaken those who seek you.
Psalm 9:10

Trust in the Lord with all your heart,
and do not lean on your own understanding.
In all your ways acknowledge him,
and he will make straight your paths.
Proverbs 3:5-6

And because of
Jesus answered, "I am the WAY and the TRUTH and the LIFE. No one comes to the Father except through me.
John 14:6 . I call myself a Follower of the Way or a Christ Seeker and consider all who believe in the Resurection of Jesus my brothers and sisters in Christ.

100%
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKMaddog on May 10, 2010, 12:20:53 AM
God is.  Jesus is.  Satan is.  Angels (both good and fallen) are.  Demons are.  We were created.  And all of the aforementioned beings are actively involved in each of our lives.

I could sit here and write a huge 20 page long post proving all of what I just said with the massive amount of evidence that I have gathered over my lifetime, but that might take too long, so I'll leave it at that.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Poe on May 10, 2010, 01:17:10 AM
I don't see why we can talk about everything else but this.
Music is in my soul and I talk about that. People argue about music all the time. There are wide points of view with music as well.
There is always going to be controversy. With everything.
I have no problem with religion talk. I'd like to know how people feel about their lives. If they think they will go somewhere after death. If you're my "family" then I don't know why I wouldn't want to know that.

I don't know. That's just me.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 10, 2010, 03:12:17 PM
I believe Religion should be practiced inside of your soul not on the forum, We don't need the Controversy that follows.

Your welcome to believe what you want but I don't see the point in openly discussing something so wide for all points of view.

well thats why i was so insistent on people not being offensive. I really am interested in what people believe, and btw, im kinda surprised at how many christians (sry for the general term  :P) are on urt. Theres usually one of these threads on every forum on the internet (except 4chan 0.0)
Ive always liked knowing theres a lot of religious people. im one of the few atheists that gives a crap, and thats just cuz i get really guilty when im mean to someone. lol. religion gives you a reason to be a good person, and without religion, our world would suck pretty badly :-\
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKMaddog on May 11, 2010, 01:26:01 AM
Ive always liked knowing theres a lot of religious people. im one of the few atheists that gives a crap, and thats just cuz i get really guilty when im mean to someone. lol. religion gives you a reason to be a good person, and without religion, our world would suck pretty badly :-\

Thats called your moral core my friend.  You feel the need to do the right thing and treat people well, and you become guilty when you fall short in that regard.  Christianity and the history behind it is what explains that moral core to me.  Its almost like we have a built-in desire for something more.  Otherwise, we would all treat the majority of people we come in contact with like total crap.  Unless we could get something out of that person, there would be zero call for us to do something for them... if not for morals.

Granted, there will always be those that use the misuse a given religion to advance their own bloody agenda.  Look at the Crusades and the violence surrounding much of the existence of Islam.  Its sad.  But overall, religion (and especially that of the Judeo-Christian variety) has done much more to further good then ill.  Examples include humanitarian aid and the medical field, but much more than those, the overall furtherance of goodwill toward others.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: bearcat on May 11, 2010, 08:15:20 AM
I believe Religion should be practiced inside of your soul not on the forum, We don't need the Controversy that follows.

Your welcome to believe what you want but I don't see the point in openly discussing something so wide for all points of view.

Rum a part of being religious is saying what you believe in are there is nothing wrong with that
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: bearcat on May 11, 2010, 03:36:24 PM
I believe Religion should be practiced inside of your soul not on the forum, We don't need the Controversy that follows.

Your welcome to believe what you want but I don't see the point in openly discussing something so wide for all points of view.

Rum a part of being religious is saying what you believe in are there is nothing wrong with that

True but i question peoples abilities to express their opinions without making an uproar or a  violent argument about it :P

but if you truly believe what you believe in you should be accepting of others and there shouldn't be a "violent argument "
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 11, 2010, 03:56:02 PM
Ive always liked knowing theres a lot of religious people. im one of the few atheists that gives a crap, and thats just cuz i get really guilty when im mean to someone. lol. religion gives you a reason to be a good person, and without religion, our world would suck pretty badly :-\

Thats called your moral core my friend.  You feel the need to do the right thing and treat people well, and you become guilty when you fall short in that regard.  Christianity and the history behind it is what explains that moral core to me.  Its almost like we have a built-in desire for something more.  Otherwise, we would all treat the majority of people we come in contact with like total crap.  Unless we could get something out of that person, there would be zero call for us to do something for them... if not for morals.

Granted, there will always be those that use the misuse a given religion to advance their own bloody agenda.  Look at the Crusades and the violence surrounding much of the existence of Islam.  Its sad.  But overall, religion (and especially that of the Judeo-Christian variety) has done much more to further good then ill.  Examples include humanitarian aid and the medical field, but much more than those, the overall furtherance of goodwill toward others.

Well for me, im pretty sure its just in how i was raised. Ive always had good manners and always been kind, but i guess thats how my parents made me... lol. It doesnt make sense to me, because a lot of people in real life are just blatant jerks to me for no reason. lol im a nerd, but i dont look like 1, most people think im a stoner :D kinda ironic, cuz ive never smoked. lol. Anyway... i have such a negative view of people in general that i dont even understand why im so nice. lol. wow that didnt sound conceited at all  :P I honestly dont see people as having mostly postive intent. I see them as selfish animals that put themselves above all. no offense, but ive always thought that was at the core of human nature. I view everything scientifically, and always have. Humans are intelligent primates. The number one instinct is survival and helping yourself. We may not have that in us anymore, but throughout my life, i havent seen anything to contradict it any more than i have seen things reinforce it. Sorry, im kinda rambling at this point... lol  :P
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: [L33Kd]Rena Ryuugu on May 12, 2010, 08:02:44 PM
I'm more of an agnostic person. I also don't have a very good view of the human race in general(including myself, i'm no different), but that's a whole other story.

If I don't see it, feel it, taste it, smell it, or hear it, I can't believe in it. I personally support the theory of evolution rather than the theory of creation, though. I don't think we'll ever figure the whole religion thing out for sure, as it'll take a ton of pretty much irretrievable evidence to prove one and disprove the other.

...it's probably better this way. It's one of those truths that could destroy us all...
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: kamikaze on May 12, 2010, 08:36:49 PM
Atheism for the win!
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Biohazard on May 12, 2010, 08:40:13 PM
I'm not much into the religious scene. Back when my family was affected by cancer I prayed and still do sometimes. But as far as I know, God never helped me with anything before. And I haven't scene any actually proof that any religion is factual.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Austinmania3 on May 12, 2010, 09:08:33 PM
as far as god to me he must hate me because nothing goes rite with my life. if there is a god he hates me if not then my life sucks. i havnt been helped at all that i know of.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: kamikaze on May 12, 2010, 10:53:11 PM
Ya that's how it is with my austin. God either hates me or does not exist. And since I am into science I tend to not believe in him and rather be logical.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: JynX on May 14, 2010, 07:41:14 AM
Atheist. I've seen no proof of him exsisting, so I see no point in believing.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Austinmania3 on May 14, 2010, 03:34:06 PM
im not saying i dont believe in him but with the way things go either he hates me or he is testing my faith hardcore
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKMaddog on May 14, 2010, 05:22:28 PM
Here's part of the problem though.  We as a people are very selfish by nature, so when we ask God for something in prayer, we only recognize him if he gives us exactly what we want.  People tell me all the time "God hardly ever answers my prayers".  Here's my answer to that: God ALWAYS answers prayers.  But he doesn't always give the answer that we desire.

God doesn't hate you guys.  Life is full of situations, both good and bad.  But my faith enables me to have a positive outcome from any situation, even if I end up getting totally screwed.  Trials give me a chance to learn how to act or react in a given situation, and I have the opportunity to become a better person because of it. 

All you who are calling yourselves Atheists, whatever you decide on is okay.  To each their own.  But I want you to realize that science and Christianity DO NOT disagree.  The only major disagreement between them is Macro-evolution (Darwinism) verses Micro-evolution/Creationism (Christianity).  I have spent countless weeks of my life studying both Creation and Macro-evolution from a scientific standpoint, and I have to tell you all that the theory that Charles Darwin promoted has some HUGE holes in it.  So huge that it would actually take far more faith for me to believe in Macro-evolution than it does for me to believe in God.

If you study Charles Darwin, you will find that he came to the same exact conclusion: There is a God, and he created the earth.  Did Darwin believe as I do that God is actively involved in all of our lives?  No.  Did he still believe in some sort of Macro-evolution?  Yes.  But he flat out confessed that his findings were flawed, and that his original intent had been only to disprove the existence of God.  But he realized that he couldn't.  Something had to intelligently start the earth as we know it. 

I'm not accusing any of you of anything.  I'm not calling you stupid.  I'm not even trying to convince you that I'm right and you're wrong.  But what I hope that the above post does is make you guys think about it, and then research the crap out of this subject with an open mind.  And if you come to the same conclusion that you already have, thats fine.  But maybe you've been mislead or maybe you overlooked something in the past.  Who knows?

Anyone with questions about any of this can reach me via PM.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 14, 2010, 08:26:03 PM
Here's part of the problem though.  We as a people are very selfish by nature, so when we ask God for something in prayer, we only recognize him if he gives us exactly what we want.  People tell me all the time "God hardly ever answers my prayers".  Here's my answer to that: God ALWAYS answers prayers.  But he doesn't always give the answer that we desire.

God doesn't hate you guys.  Life is full of situations, both good and bad.  But my faith enables me to have a positive outcome from any situation, even if I end up getting totally screwed.  Trials give me a chance to learn how to act or react in a given situation, and I have the opportunity to become a better person because of it. 

All you who are calling yourselves Atheists, whatever you decide on is okay.  To each their own.  But I want you to realize that science and Christianity DO NOT disagree.  The only major disagreement between them is Macro-evolution (Darwinism) verses Micro-evolution/Creationism (Christianity).  I have spent countless weeks of my life studying both Creation and Macro-evolution from a scientific standpoint, and I have to tell you all that the theory that Charles Darwin promoted has some HUGE holes in it.  So huge that it would actually take far more faith for me to believe in Macro-evolution than it does for me to believe in God.

If you study Charles Darwin, you will find that he came to the same exact conclusion: There is a God, and he created the earth.  Did Darwin believe as I do that God is actively involved in all of our lives?  No.  Did he still believe in some sort of Macro-evolution?  Yes.  But he flat out confessed that his findings were flawed, and that his original intent had been only to disprove the existence of God.  But he realized that he couldn't.  Something had to intelligently start the earth as we know it. 

I'm not accusing any of you of anything.  I'm not calling you stupid.  I'm not even trying to convince you that I'm right and you're wrong.  But what I hope that the above post does is make you guys think about it, and then research the crap out of this subject with an open mind.  And if you come to the same conclusion that you already have, thats fine.  But maybe you've been mislead or maybe you overlooked something in the past.  Who knows?

Anyone with questions about any of this can reach me via PM.

Ive heard a lot of people talk about darwins theory having major issues, but nobody has actually told me what they were. And im not trying to belittle christianity with this, please dont take it like that. But you say it takes more faith to believe in macro-evolution because it has holes, and yet the bible, while mostly based on true events, has no possible way of being proven in the older books, off of which the whole religion is based heavily upon. People have done extensive studies on a lot of the stories of the bible, and found explanations of them. For example, the red sea was suspected to actually be translated wrong. Historians think it was meant to be reed sea, which suggests it was a small lake. Im not too sure of the details, but i remember seeing this on the history channel. They researched it and moses and his people could have gotten to jerusalem through another route. There was a lake there and it had a wierd geological phenomenon that the tides or the ground or something changed once in a while and it made a sort of bridge across it. Even the whole book of... ok i dont remember the name. sorry. lol. but the part where god sends locusts and kills the firstborn of every family, etc, was explained, all events related to an earthquake. It did seem too coincidental to be trrue, but then again, we have been on earth for quite a while. Things like this are going to happen, and the people of that time period who couldnt explain it said it had to be an all powerful being. Im rambling a bit at this point, which i often do while talking about this sort of thing. lol. Anyway... Im certainly going to look into darwins theory, and those holes you were talking about  :P haha sry about the super long post  :-[
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 14, 2010, 10:55:26 PM
And that's something I've thought about. I honestly wish I could believe. I could die happily and live on. But if you think about it, ceasing to exist is heaven. There isn't any more pain, no more suffering... Everything is over. It's comforting to me. It may seem wierd, but eternal life scares the hell out of me. It means this will never be over. I will always be alive. Even in paradise, I wouldn't want to live forever.
And for the chaos thing: look at our universe. Everything around us is chaos. And yet, things coallesse, take shape, and order emerges from the chaos. Everything, given enough time, will reach some sort of organization. Put 10000 people on an empty continent. They wil form towns and communities and government. Everything works like this. The only
way for chaos to stay chaos is for it to sustain it's own randomness somehow. And even that could be considered a form of organization. Sry if i'm not making too much sense. I'm tired and having trouble puttin all my thoughts onto words. Lol
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Dj_Menthol on May 15, 2010, 09:39:50 AM
Atheist.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Argo on May 16, 2010, 01:08:16 AM
atheism ftw
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: [L33Kd]Rena Ryuugu on May 16, 2010, 09:30:03 PM
I'm really glad everyone here's mature enough not to flame. Hard to find mature religious conversations, yo.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 16, 2010, 11:37:27 PM
I'm really glad everyone here's mature enough not to flame. Hard to find mature religious conversations, yo.
haha yea these usually turn into massive threads of flame :D I'm proud of the maturity level here too :D
gotta love 1up <33333 lol
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: TheJuggernaut2k on May 17, 2010, 12:37:43 AM
haha :p
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: BourBon on May 17, 2010, 03:33:11 PM
Doesn't benefit anyone to be close-minded to other people's opinions.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 17, 2010, 04:21:31 PM
Doesn't benefit anyone to be close-minded to other people's opinions.
So true. I believe what i posted near the beginning, but anything could exist. God could have created the laws of physics and left no evidence of his existence for all we know. The only thing im 100% sure about is that anything could have created us
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Poe on May 17, 2010, 11:26:05 PM
I believe in God.
I don't look for any scientific proof of his existence because it seems that a major part of Christianity is faith. It wouldn't make sense to me if God gave anyone specific and undeniable proof. Of course, many people see love and hope and the trees and our human bodies as proof. Many do not. I don't know.
I don't pray often. I get angry. My life has been really, really difficult.
It's a struggle sometimes to believe in anything at all, let alone an "all powerful being". But I do anyway. And I work at being better. Even though things don't go my way I still know I'm working towards something better.
I just have never seen definite proof for God or definite proof to disprove him.


No matter what anyone believes I still love you guyz! :)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Poe on May 18, 2010, 01:39:38 PM
I believe in God.
I don't look for any scientific proof of his existence because it seems that a major part of Christianity is faith. It wouldn't make sense to me if God gave anyone specific and undeniable proof. Of course, many people see love and hope and the trees and our human bodies as proof. Many do not. I don't know.
I don't pray often. I get angry. My life has been really, really difficult.
It's a struggle sometimes to believe in anything at all, let alone an "all powerful being". But I do anyway. And I work at being better. Even though things don't go my way I still know I'm working towards something better.
I just have never seen definite proof for God or definite proof to disprove him.


No matter what anyone believes I still love you guyz! :)

Nice Poe, keeping an open mind is probably the most important thing and I am glad you can use something like spirituality to get you through the day during the rougher times, I wish the best for you.


Thank you. I've found that my belief in God has been what has saved me many times. And my faith in him. I will always think that God is the right and only way to something greater than this life... and I will always push for him first. I fail. All the time. And I'm weak. But I'm human... and I want to believe in a loving God.
I'll never condemn anyone, though. That's not my place. I try not to judge. I just slowly work at being more. Because alone I am just like everyone else, which to me is a problem. I want to be more joyful and more productive and more caring and more honest. That will take time, yes... but it's the price I'll pay for heaven.
I keep an open mind but I finally know what I believe. Science molded my beliefs for a long time but I had an amazing physics teacher and chemistry teacher (who was taking a break from building bombs for the government, which was weird) who showed me that I can believe in science and my faith. So, I do. I keep my science and my God.
But, at the end of the day I just want to be able to say that I showed someone love.  :)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 18, 2010, 03:22:19 PM
So first of all, i need to say this. please, nobody get angry or offensive in how they present their views. Dont try to make anyone mad, because you will just look like a jerk. Ive always been interested in this kind of thing, and what people believe, I personally believe in existiential nihilism, the belief that we are just another anomaly in the universe, and that human life is meaningless. However, most people believe different things. Post your views or arguments, because im very curious in what all of you believe  :D

Remember, i dont want this topic closed down. BE POLITE!!!! lol

I follow existentialism but I am not a nihilist. I do not understand how life can be meaningless, can you provide some resources or insight to this belief? It does not make sense - life is what we make of it and if you want to get down to the bare basics, like some sort of biological machine, then it is the continuation of the specie - survival. Try telling your cells they serve no purpose lol, they would say "F*** you, we are just trying to survive". I would not disagree that we are an anomaly, I am not sure what the numbers are , in terms of probability and the chance of getting a planet like earth when looking at what else is out there, off the top of my head but the suitable conditions to support the evolution of life, as we know it, are very specific and we lucked out.

Well one thing ive always strongly believed is that the number 1 instinct is survival and reproduction. Look closely at anything you do. It all stems back to either survival, reproduction, or pleasure. Survival and reproduction are base instincts. With pleasure, ive always seen it like training animals. we get rewarded for doing things our body likes. I really dont have resources or anything, its just based on the proof ive seen of science and not of religion. And "anomalies" like us are bound to happen quite a bit. If the universe is infinite, or even as large as currently thought, theres going to be a lot of life. Our way of life based on DNA and things like that could be incredibly different than anything else, though. In fact, it is extremely rare to find a planet like ours. However, ours isnt the only kind of conceivable life. There are molecules called prions (i think thats what they are called), and they cause disease among deer by replicating through reactions in the deer. If 1 molecule can create life, or near life, then life cant be as rare as we think. Life on another planet could be based on the gases and minerals on that planet, and have whole other subprocesses within the ecosystem. Instead of predators and such, all the creatures could feed off of minerals, or filter gases out of the air. If life of other kinds is on other planets, why is ours the creation of a god? Why would ours be any different?
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Poe on May 18, 2010, 03:45:17 PM
Well one thing ive always strongly believed is that the number 1 instinct is survival and reproduction. Look closely at anything you do. It all stems back to either survival, reproduction, or pleasure. Survival and reproduction are base instincts. With pleasure, ive always seen it like training animals. we get rewarded for doing things our body likes. I really dont have resources or anything, its just based on the proof ive seen of science and not of religion.

I believe in God and definitely believe we are born with basic instincts. Totally. Survival, reproduction and pleasure. Yes. Those things, and many others, we are all born with. But things like that are things Christians believe in also.
I don't think Christianity has to go against science. I love science and I think it goes hand in hand with my faith in a God.

Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: |$|CandyMan on May 18, 2010, 06:08:43 PM
Think about this. If I told you right now that there is a teapot orbiting Neptune and if you really believe you can speak to it inside your head. And if you ask it something it will do it unless it deems you unworthy of its Chai goodness. It is also a very secretive teapot and will make it's self invisible and intangible because it can. Would you believe me? If you have a fraction of an ounce of common sense you will say no.

At the beginning of this thread people were talking about how they were christian. Then someone made a comment about someone else being atheist. Why fight? Us atheists and christians aren't very different at all. Atheists only believe in one god fewer than christians do.

I'm fine with religion as long as it doesn't lead to violence or ignorance. Listen to science, the sun doesn't revolve around the earth.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 18, 2010, 07:32:38 PM
Why fight? Us atheists and christians aren't very different at all. Atheists only believe in one god fewer than christians do.
Lawl!!! thats one of my favorite quotes evar :D
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 18, 2010, 07:40:14 PM
I don't think Christianity has to go against science. I love science and I think it goes hand in hand with my faith in a God.
Thats one of the reasons i think anything is possible. The laws of physics do work, but god may have created them that way. For that reason, the debate between science and religion will never end. However, i have a bit of a challenge for the religious people on this thread. Can you give us proof that god exists? Science has plenty of proof. Look back on history. The church taught that the solar system revolved around earth. Men that opposed that idea were ridiculed, and even killed sometimes. Now, we know that we revolve around the sun. Science has been proven over religion in the past through proof. If someone can us proof that god exists, ill definitly start taking religion more seriously. Dont just say the bible. True, it is based on past events, but like i said before, they take a bunch of wierd occurences and coincidences and say god is responsible. Dont say the love in people, either. Some have made his argument, but you see the same thing in animals. They die for their young, or pregnant mate. They defend friends who could end up as prey otherwise. Give me some sort of proof, and i will look into it for sure.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: JynX on May 18, 2010, 08:26:26 PM
So what you are saying is for all the none christians in the entire world, or for the people who do not believe in god or jesus, they are all going to hell? That really sux... since they have their own religion based on where they come from...
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Poe on May 18, 2010, 08:34:22 PM
I think a religion in which you require proof excludes faith, which is key to most religions.

Agreed. I don't think there will ever be 100% proof of the existence of God. I never expect there to be. It just wouldn't make sense. I also don't think there will ever be 100% proof against God.

Think about this. If I told you right now that there is a teapot orbiting Neptune and if you really believe you can speak to it inside your head. And if you ask it something it will do it unless it deems you unworthy of its Chai goodness. It is also a very secretive teapot and will make it's self invisible and intangible because it can. Would you believe me? If you have a fraction of an ounce of common sense you will say no.


Well, if you proposed this and a enormous, unknown number of humans followed and had faith in this for over 200, 000 years (archeologists numbers/science numbers), then maybe I would believe you.
Anyone can create their own God. But to have millions and millions of people believe in only one... it takes more common sense for me to say yes.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Poe on May 18, 2010, 08:36:45 PM
Also, I'm really happy that this thread has gone the way it has. Mature and serious discussions vs. ridiculous name calling and such. You guys are so awesome!
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 18, 2010, 08:38:03 PM
That seems dumb to me. How can an "all loving god" let people in 3rd world countries who never even heard of christianity go to hell because they dont even know what christianity is? Thats extremely unfair. Thats as bad as back when the church believed only higher class people could go to heaven :/

Also, I'm really happy that this thread has gone the way it has. Mature and serious discussions vs. ridiculous name calling and such. You guys are so awesome!

Haha im glad with how it went too :D
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: JynX on May 18, 2010, 08:39:25 PM
Agreed!
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Poe on May 18, 2010, 08:45:43 PM
That seems dumb to me. How can an "all loving god" let people in 3rd world countries who never even heard of christianity go to hell because they dont even know what christianity is? Thats extremely unfair. Thats as bad as back when the church believed only higher class people could go to heaven :/


I don't know how God determines all of that. I know that God offers Grace. Maybe that's the answer.
I'll never know... but I don't think we could ever know for sure how God works. Do I think that every person who hasn't heard of God is going to hell? No, I don't. Do I know for sure? No.
But I know that God is loving. And forgiving. And gives me strength. God judges differently than we do because he see's it all from every possible angle.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: JynX on May 18, 2010, 08:56:51 PM
But from what I've heard and somewhat read from the bible myself, You cannot get into heaven unless you believe in God's son, Jesus. How can you believe in someone you have never heard of? Or if you have lived around a different religion your entire life?

And second. To some really big christians that go to church every sunday. I understand you may believe in him a lot. But how do you know for sure that there is a heaven, and that you will go? Why waste a perfect sunday for sleeping to go to church?

I went to Youth Group with my friend. I tried it all out. I just didn't quite get it at all.. But even her preacher or w.e. you wanna call it, even he said "It IS only a belief." Yes, faith counts for a lot. But what if you spend so much of your time, prayers, and faith on something to later find out that there is no heaven? I'd rather just live my life, and die. As all that is suppose to happen, instead of trying to believe in something or have faith in something to possibly later to find there is no such thing and to possibly be let down...
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: JynX on May 18, 2010, 09:05:49 PM
Lol, yea.. me too. (: good talking with you all!
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Poe on May 18, 2010, 09:07:29 PM

I went to Youth Group with my friend. I tried it all out. I just didn't quite get it at all.. But even her preacher or w.e. you wanna call it, even he said "It IS only a belief." Yes, faith counts for a lot. But what if you spend so much of your time, prayers, and faith on something to later find out that there is no heaven? I'd rather just live my life, and die. As all that is suppose to happen, instead of trying to believe in something or have faith in something to possibly later to find there is no such thing and to possibly be let down...

I've lived life. I've lived a worldly, unhappy (at times)  life. Abuse to adoption. Happy times with drunk friends. Years addicted to crystal meth and cocaine. Suicide attempts. Being one of the most popular kids in school. Sports. Sorority in college. Boys. Ha. I've lived that life. And ya know, I really miss it sometimes... I miss being carefree. Sleeping in. Wasting time.
But now I don't.
I will never, ever regret living (or, attempting to live) a Christian lifestyle. What's bad about it? You live. You have motivation to be good - To be faithful to your spouse. To serve others. To volunteer. To hope.
If there isn't a God, I wont be let down. That faith is helping me to be someone worth being. I hope to be living my life like this forever.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: White^lynx on May 18, 2010, 09:10:54 PM
Supposedly God gave us "free will" so how is it free will if he is going to MAKE US believe in him and if we dont we go to Hell. For me i believe that anything that we truly think is right and have no question against it, whether its budhism or christianity or athiesm it is true. For me  belive there is a God, but i dont believe that he will ever intervene here on Earth. So i dont pray or go to church like other christians do.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: JACk46d9 on May 18, 2010, 10:13:51 PM
  everything is true and left to interpretation. its much more scientific and simple than mystical. i think everyone will be surprised how simple it all is. i would look back as far as history will allow. the people who were first here tens of  thousands of years ago and look at what they say happened. what do the egyptians say. mayan. whoever. they all say we were visited. our gods came from "the heavens" this doesnt mean that the bible is not true its just who was behind it.

http://www.alien-ufo-pictures.com/ancient_aliens.html (http://www.alien-ufo-pictures.com/ancient_aliens.html)

Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 18, 2010, 10:30:35 PM
My "mere" belief is worth more to me than anything.  ;)

p.s. I gotta be done with the thread.
lol why do u gotta be done? I liked your input lol  ;)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKMaddog on May 19, 2010, 12:30:13 AM
Looking this over, I found many things that I would like to address, particularly pertaining to the scientific side of things.  Its gonna be a novel, and I don't have time to do it now, but hopefully I can find some time this weekend to make a good post.

Its interesting to see all of your input.  I mean this very nicely, but a few of you seem to be fairly ignorant of science and world/religious history.  But a few of you seem very well versed in certain aspects of this conversation.  I don't pretend to be a genius, bit I am VERY logical and have at the very least a moderate amount of knowledge on this subject.  Like I said previously, I dedicated a large portion of my life to studying this specific issue.  Hopefully I can some of my findings in a concise and articulate manner.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: |$|CandyMan on May 19, 2010, 01:14:56 AM
Well, if you proposed this and a enormous, unknown number of humans followed and had faith in this for over 200, 000 years (archeologists numbers/science numbers), then maybe I would believe you.
Anyone can create their own God. But to have millions and millions of people believe in only one... it takes more common sense for me to say yes.

When I read that I lost a great deal of faith in humanity.
If every single person in the world believe I was a unicorn that shat rainbows, it would not change the fact that I am not a rainbow sh*tting unicorn.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Poe on May 19, 2010, 01:51:34 PM
Well, if you proposed this and a enormous, unknown number of humans followed and had faith in this for over 200, 000 years (archeologists numbers/science numbers), then maybe I would believe you.
Anyone can create their own God. But to have millions and millions of people believe in only one... it takes more common sense for me to say yes.

When I read that I lost a great deal of faith in humanity.
If every single person in the world believe I was a unicorn that shat rainbows, it would not change the fact that I am not a rainbow sh*tting unicorn.

Well, your analogy made me laugh... and that's as much as I'll say.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 19, 2010, 03:03:42 PM
Well, if you proposed this and a enormous, unknown number of humans followed and had faith in this for over 200, 000 years (archeologists numbers/science numbers), then maybe I would believe you.
Anyone can create their own God. But to have millions and millions of people believe in only one... it takes more common sense for me to say yes.

When I read that I lost a great deal of faith in humanity.
If every single person in the world believe I was a unicorn that shat rainbows, it would not change the fact that I am not a rainbow sh*tting unicorn.

Well the whole world wouldnt believe something like that. Hell, somewhere in the world, someone may believe that the world is flat. The whole world is never going to agree on anything. But as for the millions of people believeing one god... The whole world believes lots of different religions. Christianity is only as big as bhuddism, islam, and other large religions. In fact, those religions have been around longer than christianity. And even if the entire world was christian... Choosing your religion based on what everybody else believes is dumb. You are supposed to find the answers yourself, not to follow the croud.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Poe on May 19, 2010, 03:29:54 PM
Choosing your religion based on what everybody else believes is dumb. You are supposed to find the answers yourself, not to follow the croud.

No, I agree. Most of my friends don't believe but I still do.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Poe on May 19, 2010, 03:39:54 PM
Hey guys. I'm sorry. I shouldn't have kept posting.
The only thing I know is that I've lived a life without God and I've lived a life with God... and my life didn't make any sense without him. I can't prove he exists.
People fight for what they believe and that's all I was trying to do. Which I shouldn't.
Believe or not, I still respect all of your opinions. I don't want to come off as a jerk, and I hope I haven't in my last posts. I just know that there is significant proof in my life that shows that faith in God can change someone.
That's all.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKMaddog on May 19, 2010, 04:36:12 PM
Christianity is only as big as bhuddism, islam, and other large religions. In fact, those religions have been around longer than christianity.

Judaism was the first religion.  Christianity comes directly from Judaism.  Its the fulfillment of the Jewish faith and directly draws upon the original Jewish law.

Islam also came from Judaism.  Geographical and social differences evolved Judaism into Islam, which holds Muhammad as its highest prophet.

Bhuddism was created by a Hindu man.

The bottom line is that many (not all) of the religions come back to a common point.  I have a lot to say about this issue, and about which one should be regarded as the correct religion based on that common point, but I won't because I don't wish to offend.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 19, 2010, 04:42:01 PM
Christianity is only as big as bhuddism, islam, and other large religions. In fact, those religions have been around longer than christianity.

Judaism was the first religion.  Christianity comes directly from Judaism.  Its the fulfillment of the Jewish faith and directly draws upon the original Jewish law.

Islam also came from Judaism.  Geographical and social differences evolved Judaism into Islam, which holds Muhammad as its highest prophet.

Bhuddism was created by a Hindu man.

The bottom line is that many (not all) of the religions come back to a common point.  I have a lot to say about this issue, and about which one should be regarded as the correct religion based on that common point, but I won't because I don't wish to offend.
haha its impossible to offend me :D but what i mean is why christianity? why not another religion that stems off of judaism? If you believe judaism is right and others stem from it, why not follow judaism?
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: |$|CandyMan on May 19, 2010, 05:03:34 PM
Well the whole world wouldnt believe something like that. Hell, somewhere in the world, someone may believe that the world is flat. The whole world is never going to agree on anything. But as for the millions of people believeing one god... The whole world believes lots of different religions. Christianity is only as big as bhuddism, islam, and other large religions. In fact, those religions have been around longer than christianity. And even if the entire world was christian... Choosing your religion based on what everybody else believes is dumb. You are supposed to find the answers yourself, not to follow the croud.

Many kids don't get a chance to choose for themselves because their parents jam their beliefs into them before they can even understand it.

I don't have a problem with people believing in a god or the afterlife but if they ever use that as an excuse to commit atrocities, such as the crusades or 9/11 or even a single murder or attack, that's when it crosses the line.

IMHO God(Christian God), the alleged creator of the universe, bearer of all knowledge, creator of mankind, would not be so vain as to require that a person need only believe in him/her in order to get into heaven.
"For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son,[a] that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life." - John 3:16
Going by this criteria Hitler has a better chance of getting into heaven than I do.

The concept of heaven was created by man in order to ease the fear of death.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 19, 2010, 05:13:25 PM
Well the whole world wouldnt believe something like that. Hell, somewhere in the world, someone may believe that the world is flat. The whole world is never going to agree on anything. But as for the millions of people believeing one god... The whole world believes lots of different religions. Christianity is only as big as bhuddism, islam, and other large religions. In fact, those religions have been around longer than christianity. And even if the entire world was christian... Choosing your religion based on what everybody else believes is dumb. You are supposed to find the answers yourself, not to follow the croud.

Many kids don't get a chance to choose for themselves because their parents jam their beliefs into them before they can even understand it.

I don't have a problem with people believing in a god or the afterlife but if they ever use that as an excuse to commit atrocities, such as the crusades or 9/11 or even a single murder or attack, that's when it crosses the line.

IMHO God(Christian God), the alleged creator of the universe, bearer of all knowledge, creator of mankind, would not be so vain as to require that a person need only believe in him/her in order to get into heaven.
"For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son,[a] that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life." - John 3:16
Going by this criteria Hitler has a better chance of getting into heaven than I do.

The concept of heaven was created by man in order to ease the fear of death.

Ive had christianity crammed down my throat my whole life. You always have a choice. Maybe not in what you do, but what you believe.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 20, 2010, 03:02:27 PM
  everything is true and left to interpretation. its much more scientific and simple than mystical. i think everyone will be surprised how simple it all is. i would look back as far as history will allow. the people who were first here tens of  thousands of years ago and look at what they say happened. what do the egyptians say. mayan. whoever. they all say we were visited. our gods came from "the heavens" this doesnt mean that the bible is not true its just who was behind it.

http://www.alien-ufo-pictures.com/ancient_aliens.html (http://www.alien-ufo-pictures.com/ancient_aliens.html)

When i first read that, i read the first sentence and figured u meant it as anything could exist, kinda like what i posted before on here. I just read the whole thing, and realized it was talking about aliens 0.0 lol im open to everything, like i said. I actually believe in aliens. Not the kind that come to earth or whatever, the speed of light limits space travel too much. But i do believe life exists outside our own planet. Its possible that a probe could have crashed here and left alien life, which we are descendants of. But if they had so much technology, why were we left using sticks and stones for so long?
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKQuaKe on May 20, 2010, 10:21:52 PM
Well the whole world wouldnt believe something like that. Hell, somewhere in the world, someone may believe that the world is flat. The whole world is never going to agree on anything. But as for the millions of people believeing one god... The whole world believes lots of different religions. Christianity is only as big as bhuddism, islam, and other large religions. In fact, those religions have been around longer than christianity. And even if the entire world was christian... Choosing your religion based on what everybody else believes is dumb. You are supposed to find the answers yourself, not to follow the croud.

Many kids don't get a chance to choose for themselves because their parents jam their beliefs into them before they can even understand it.

I don't have a problem with people believing in a god or the afterlife but if they ever use that as an excuse to commit atrocities, such as the crusades or 9/11 or even a single murder or attack, that's when it crosses the line.

IMHO God(Christian God), the alleged creator of the universe, bearer of all knowledge, creator of mankind, would not be so vain as to require that a person need only believe in him/her in order to get into heaven.
"For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son,[a] that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life." - John 3:16
Going by this criteria Hitler has a better chance of getting into heaven than I do.

The concept of heaven was created by man in order to ease the fear of death.

Im not afraid of death and in reality my world would not be turned upside down if God did not exist. Even though i strongly believe the world was created and not evolved from nothing. If I could find evidence that proved otherwise I would say party!
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKQuaKe on May 20, 2010, 10:43:47 PM
The human brain has been estimated to contain 50–100 billion (1011) neurons, of which about 10 billion (1010) are cortical pyramidal cells. These cells pass signals to each other via as many as 1000 trillion (1015) synaptic connections.[2]
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 21, 2010, 05:16:51 PM
The human brain has been estimated to contain 50–100 billion (1011) neurons, of which about 10 billion (1010) are cortical pyramidal cells. These cells pass signals to each other via as many as 1000 trillion (1015) synaptic connections.[2]
sorry i feel like im about to look really stupid asking this but where did that come from? i cant see any way that was related to the conversation  :-[
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKQuaKe on May 21, 2010, 09:33:18 PM
Ah its just something to think about, As far is how complex it is... How long would it take to evolve that puppy? :)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 21, 2010, 11:50:09 PM
Ah its just something to think about, As far is how complex it is... How long would it take to evolve that puppy? :)
haha ok I get it now :D billions and billions of years. Which we have had :p lol
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: JACk46d9 on May 22, 2010, 06:16:50 AM
dude redrum, that **** was so funny i laughed my ass off ahahahahahahahah southpark rules !!!!!
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on May 22, 2010, 10:19:19 AM
WIN!!!!! WIN!!!!! WIN!!!!! hahaha +1 :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: LoveoftheDark on May 23, 2010, 08:58:54 PM
I was raised to believe that there was only one God, and that those who did not believe would burn in hell...


Well, I guess I'll take hell, because I have too many friends of differing religions, and I feel like a hypocrite telling them that because of how they were raised and what they were told, that they are going to hell...when in fact, some of them may have the correct answer. until God calls me on the phone or appears in my car to say...HEY, This is the right way, then I have no choice but to be open minded and hope that theres a good place for everyone when we die.
Besides...
The biblical "Father" Is supposed to be a perfect Father, right? What would a perfect Father do? Punish his children for all eternity for having a disagreement with him? Expose his beloved children to the lake of fire forever because they never heard about him? (there are plenty of places who have other religions, far older than the 2000 year old christianity) Nah...it doesn't add up.

Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKQuaKe on June 08, 2010, 04:16:27 PM
I was raised to believe that there was only one God, and that those who did not believe would burn in hell...


Well, I guess I'll take hell, because I have too many friends of differing religions, and I feel like a hypocrite telling them that because of how they were raised and what they were told, that they are going to hell...when in fact, some of them may have the correct answer. until God calls me on the phone or appears in my car to say...HEY, This is the right way, then I have no choice but to be open minded and hope that theres a good place for everyone when we die.
Besides...
The biblical "Father" Is supposed to be a perfect Father, right? What would a perfect Father do? Punish his children for all eternity for having a disagreement with him? Expose his beloved children to the lake of fire forever because they never heard about him? (there are plenty of places who have other religions, far older than the 2000 year old christianity) Nah...it doesn't add up.

Throw some facts in there.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKQuaKe on June 08, 2010, 04:23:33 PM
Scientists say Life came from matter but they can't prove it. That is essential to the theory of Evolution.









Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKQuaKe on June 08, 2010, 04:52:10 PM
Ah its just something to think about, As far is how complex it is... How long would it take to evolve that puppy? :)
haha ok I get it now :D billions and billions of years. Which we have had :p lol

I find it interesting that 70% of mutations are DAMAGING. And the rest are neutral or weakly beneficial.
Take 1 step forward 2 steps back. We are devolving.


Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on June 08, 2010, 05:07:27 PM
But back before we had all this technology, a mutation would either cause us to be deformed (unnattractive) and we couldnt reproduce, or we wouldnt live long enough to pass on our genes. Of course, that was before pity and science :D
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKQuaKe on June 08, 2010, 06:42:15 PM
But back before we had all this technology, a mutation would either cause us to be deformed (unnattractive) and we couldnt reproduce, or we wouldnt live long enough to pass on our genes. Of course, that was before pity and science :D

I think damaged genes are why lifespans are getting shorter. Modern Technology is just that, And has not been around very long. But is helping us do what our bodies no longer can. (Fight disease)

Don't you find it strange that man according to evolution and the speed that things evolve,  have been at our current stange of evolution for a really long ass time. And we just now achieved the technology level we are at NOW..... We are extremely primitive. It did not take LONG at all to achieve this level of technology. And if 1 good evolutionary change takes a million years or even 50,000 years, Where is our past? Why are  we not  flying around in spaceships already.




Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKMaddog on June 08, 2010, 07:13:10 PM
And if 1 good evolutionary change takes a million years or even 50,000 years, Where is our past? Why are  we not  flying around in spaceships already.

True.  Star Trek would be much closer to reality if mainstream School-taught Science were accurate. 

I'm still gonna chime in on this.  Just dreading the multiple hours it will take me to write an informative and articulate post containing my findings on the matter...
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on June 08, 2010, 07:23:05 PM
Haha well our technology hasnt been around too long. Most of the evolution occured before we were even advanced enough to use sticks to eat bugs. The major part of our evolution is from single cell to multi cell. from there, it was just how the cells coallese. Its like building a car. It would take longest to make the individual pieces one bye one than it would to put them together and make a vehicle
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Tits_McGee on June 11, 2010, 01:41:54 PM
I am an atheist buddhist. They are not mutally exclusive despite what a lot of people think. I don't mind believers though, after all I married a born again christian.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: inka on June 13, 2010, 07:00:32 AM
Quote
I am an atheist buddhist.
In my opinion that is the best religeon It encouages people to be nice to everyone and every thing.
   :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D  :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on June 13, 2010, 11:51:37 AM
Haha i feel dumb for not knowing this, but what is atheistic bhuddism?
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on June 13, 2010, 07:04:52 PM
Haha sounds good :D
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SlimPickins on June 15, 2010, 02:53:36 AM
I believe that whatever you believe is the right thing to believe in. A major problem with organized religion is that the followers feel the need to justify their beliefs by convincing others that it's the right thing to believe. It's like they can't feel sure of themselves for their beliefs unless everyone else believes in the same things. I give the same answer to people who ask about what the best Linux distro is (I know it sounds dumb, but it's totally the same thing): Pick the one that's right for YOU. It doesn't matter what everyone else thinks. Once you can bring yourself to do this and truly believe in what you believe in regardless of what other believe in... well, then I *believe* you'll be fine...

 - Pickins
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: ojacker on June 28, 2010, 08:11:01 PM
I am a unique christian. I do lead bible studies and love to read my bible, but I believe that the fact that u believe in somthing more (be it God, or any other) helps u withstand the tough times. I do not press my beliefs on to others and I believe that the devision of the church is wrong because, as christians, how can we function togeather if we are all devided and fighting over what is right and what is wrong. respecting others should be top priority. I have argued beliefs with a scientologist for hours but afterward being able to honestly say, I respect what you believe in and love you the same as anyone else. so in that sence, I guess I am a christian who believes in RESPECT and freedom of choice. as allways... peace (-<)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: novabunny on July 09, 2010, 12:28:25 AM
 :o :o :o :o ??? ??? ???ahhhhhhhhhhhhhh i got a headache i'm only 11 :'( ahhhh big headache.......it hurts
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: ZakBain on July 10, 2010, 08:02:44 PM
Three interesting papers/essays written by Bertrand Russell:

Has Religion Made Useful Contributions to Civilization?, Bertrand Russell (http://www.positiveatheism.org/hist/russell2.htm)
Why I am not a Christian, Bertrand Russell (http://users.drew.edu/~jlenz/whynot.html)
Why I am a Rationalist, Bertrand Russell (http://www.positiveatheism.org/hist/russell7.htm)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Biohazard on July 11, 2010, 04:31:46 PM
Seriously Zak? I haven't seen you around in ages, but I was wondering where you ran off to just a few days ago.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: ZakBain on July 11, 2010, 09:24:56 PM
Seriously Zak? I haven't seen you around in ages, but I was wondering where you ran off to just a few days ago.

Well, my interest in gaming has gone from overwhelming to almost none; I've shown up in the forums every now and then. Never really had anything worth saying.
Also, is the serious referring to my absence or my previous post?
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Biohazard on July 11, 2010, 09:48:36 PM
Ahhh, your absence, sorry Zak. I know what you mean though. A break from gaming is nice :)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on September 10, 2010, 07:18:44 AM
So first of all, i need to say this. please, nobody get angry or offensive in how they present their views. Dont try to make anyone mad, because you will just look like a jerk. Ive always been interested in this kind of thing, and what people believe, I personally believe in existiential nihilism, the belief that we are just another anomaly in the universe, and that human life is meaningless. However, most people believe different things. Post your views or arguments, because im very curious in what all of you believe  :D

Remember, i dont want this topic closed down. BE POLITE!!!! lol
I BELIEVE ALIENS CREEATED OUR GALAXY AS A TEST SUBJECT
You know, that's 100% possible. From the viewpoint of seeing science as ruling the galaxy, it's more likely than an omniscient being creating the universe. Although it probably wouldn't be our galaxy, maybe just terraformed our planet or just put basic life on it
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: BourBon on September 10, 2010, 10:53:17 PM
I think it takes more faith to not believe in a greater being simply because if you believe in science you believe in multiple unknown possibilities, believe in a greater being there's only one unknown possibility.  : \ 
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on September 11, 2010, 09:52:09 AM
I think it takes more faith to not believe in a greater being simply because if you believe in science you believe in multiple unknown possibilities, believe in a greater being there's only one unknown possibility.  : \
Everything takes faith. Knowing the sun will come up the next morning takes faith. I've always seen science as taking less faith, because we see proof of it everyday. And no matter what the subject, there will always be unknown possibilities. Even in Christianity: do you know what heaven is like? Do you know if god is going to forgive the sins you've made? A lot of these unknowns don't make too big of a difference to the big picture, but it's the same way with science. And btw, you gotta add Boobs to your nickname list ;p
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKMaddog on September 11, 2010, 11:53:54 PM
I think it takes more faith to not believe in a greater being simply because if you believe in science you believe in multiple unknown possibilities, believe in a greater being there's only one unknown possibility.  : \
Everything takes faith. Knowing the sun will come up the next morning takes faith. I've always seen science as taking less faith, because we see proof of it everyday. And no matter what the subject, there will always be unknown possibilities. Even in Christianity: do you know what heaven is like? Do you know if god is going to forgive the sins you've made? A lot of these unknowns don't make too big of a difference to the big picture, but it's the same way with science. And btw, you gotta add Boobs to your nickname list ;p

Its not a matter of science vs Christianity.  Its a matter of Macro-Evolution vs Creation.  MAINSTREAM science is in disagreement with Creation.  But think about it.  What bourbon was trying to say is that with Creation, I only have to believe in one thing that doesn't make sense.  With Darwin's Theory of Evolution, there are literally thousands of things that don't make sense.  Charles Darwin even turned away from the Macro-Evolution theory after realizing this.  Why are none of these thousands of things discussed?  Because for the last 30 years or so, there has been a coordinated push to unify the teaching information in such a way that God is completely left out of the picture.  If you look at this from the outside with zero bias, it pretty obvious.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKQuaKe on September 12, 2010, 12:53:17 AM
I think everyone knows there is a God, Because its evident in the order of the universe and the need was put in us when we were created.. Why a person chooses to ignore the truth.. Well.. I have a few good theories.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKMaddog on September 12, 2010, 01:39:10 AM
I think everyone knows there is a God, Because its evident in the order of the universe and the need was put in us when we were created.. Why a person chooses to ignore the truth.. Well.. I have a few good theories.

I agree.  Everything works too well for this to all be from chance.  I think that's becoming more and more clear to people as time goes on.  Hell, even on the Discovery Channel when they're doing a "strange animal" show, the narrator often describes a certain unique characteristic of a creature as having been "designed" to do something specific.  Though the Discover Channel propagates the Macro-Evolution theory, sometimes outside design is so obvious to the subconscious that the writers make a faux pas.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on September 12, 2010, 12:19:15 PM
I think it takes more faith to not believe in a greater being simply because if you believe in science you believe in multiple unknown possibilities, believe in a greater being there's only one unknown possibility.  : \
Everything takes faith. Knowing the sun will come up the next morning takes faith. I've always seen science as taking less faith, because we see proof of it everyday. And no matter what the subject, there will always be unknown possibilities. Even in Christianity: do you know what heaven is like? Do you know if god is going to forgive the sins you've made? A lot of these unknowns don't make too big of a difference to the big picture, but it's the same way with science. And btw, you gotta add Boobs to your nickname list ;p

Its not a matter of science vs Christianity.  Its a matter of Macro-Evolution vs Creation.  MAINSTREAM science is in disagreement with Creation.  But think about it.  What bourbon was trying to say is that with Creation, I only have to believe in one thing that doesn't make sense.  With Darwin's Theory of Evolution, there are literally thousands of things that don't make sense.  Charles Darwin even turned away from the Macro-Evolution theory after realizing this.  Why are none of these thousands of things discussed?  Because for the last 30 years or so, there has been a coordinated push to unify the teaching information in such a way that God is completely left out of the picture.  If you look at this from the outside with zero bias, it pretty obvious.
Ive actually looked up a lot of these issues with evolution, and while a lot dont make sense, a lot are also explainable. And as for intelligent design, that is explained by evolution. one issue with evolution was always that the whole organ didnt develop at once, because it was a lot of advanced parts working together. but, look at the sense of hearing. It most likely started as just a highly sensitive part on the body, just a few extra nerves bundled together. and over time, it went from just feeling vibrations (probably in the water) to being a seperate, distinguished sense. organs with simple uses can evolve to do much more complex things than their original intent. And also, everybody subconsciously thinks of there being a god. but i dont stop saying "oh my god" just because i dont believe there is a god. The narrator said it was designed for something, because its easier to say.Its not like hes going to say "this part evolved over millions of years to..." because it takes longer. haha
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Zangetsu on September 17, 2010, 02:06:39 AM
Personally I don't believe in God. I don't believe he doesn't exist either. I'm pretty agnostic about religion, if he's there then he's there. If not, oh well. I would rather live MY life doing good because it makes ME feel good. Not because some book written over a thousand years ago in a language that is pretty much lost in time says I should do so.

I also wrote a big long thing down here but decided not to pst it. I reread it and it seemed like a bunch of flame so I'll just leave my post at this.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on September 17, 2010, 05:03:09 PM
Personally I don't believe in God. I don't believe he doesn't exist either. I'm pretty agnostic about religion, if he's there then he's there. If not, oh well. I would rather live MY life doing good because it makes ME feel good. Not because some book written over a thousand years ago in a language that is pretty much lost in time says I should do so.

I also wrote a big long thing down here but decided not to pst it. I reread it and it seemed like a bunch of flame so I'll just leave my post at this.
Ahaha i have to keep watching what i say too, dont wanna piss any1 off :p
Thats how ive always seen things. Id rather live the way that makes me happy, rather than living for someone im not even sure exists. Although, most stories in the bible have been proven true. A lot were majorly exaggerated, like the great flood, that was most likely just a flood in the middle east, in a time when it was below sea level, and a river formed from the ocean into it. (i paraphrased alot, havent seen that history special in a long while)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKMaddog on September 17, 2010, 06:42:36 PM
Although, most stories in the bible have been proven true. A lot were majorly exaggerated, like the great flood, that was most likely just a flood in the middle east, in a time when it was below sea level, and a river formed from the ocean into it. (i paraphrased alot, havent seen that history special in a long while)

How come over 500 different cultures around the world have old stories of a world-wide flood?  How do you explain the Grand Canyon?  If you would just research things a bit before towing the conventional "scientific" line, you would have better arguments.  Research the Grand Canyon.  Look at topographical maps of the SW US.  Research other cultural confirmations of the great flood.  Research the Mount St Helen's eruption, and the subsequent flooding and rapid layered canyon creation.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: White^lynx on September 18, 2010, 01:16:43 AM
The church and what were learnign in school about religion has changed recently. The church doesnt actually believe in the adam and eve and the creation story. We are learning its a just a story to show how divine and powerful God is. They are teaching us that God set everything in motion from the beginning to make us who we are today.

Just thought id let you guys in on how the church sees this now a days.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKMaddog on September 18, 2010, 02:06:38 AM
The church and what were learnign in school about religion has changed recently. The church doesnt actually believe in the adam and eve and the creation story. We are learning its a just a story to show how divine and powerful God is. They are teaching us that God set everything in motion from the beginning to make us who we are today.

Just thought id let you guys in on how the church sees this now a days.

What church are you referring to?  My Christianity is based 100% on the Bible.  The church I'm affiliated with is the same way.  Why?  Because almost everything in the Bible can be proven as factual.  Give it your best shot.  There isn't much that can't be explained or historically verified in there.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on September 18, 2010, 12:33:23 PM
Nearly everything with physical proof has some sort of discrepancies. I'm not going to sit here and pretend I know everything, I'm only 16, that would be stupid. But the issue with this argument is that it will never be resolved. People have been adding to and changing religion much longer than science, it's going to have sounder arguments. But look at all the times religion has been wrong: first, the church believed the earth was the center of the universe. It was later proven it wasn't. The church believed in witches, and killed innocent people because of it. I know science hasn't been right 100 percent of the time, but it's newer than religion. The first religions started as just superstitions, like eating the heart of your hunt makes you stronger. Science and religion have both changed, and neither will ever be 100 percent right, no matter if there is or isn't a god.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKQuaKe on September 18, 2010, 01:34:23 PM
lol
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on September 18, 2010, 01:42:34 PM
lol
what a compelling argument :)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKMaddog on September 18, 2010, 02:23:30 PM
Nearly everything with physical proof has some sort of discrepancies. I'm not going to sit here and pretend I know everything, I'm only 16, that would be stupid. But the issue with this argument is that it will never be resolved. People have been adding to and changing religion much longer than science, it's going to have sounder arguments. But look at all the times religion has been wrong: first, the church believed the earth was the center of the universe. It was later proven it wasn't. The church believed in witches, and killed innocent people because of it. I know science hasn't been right 100 percent of the time, but it's newer than religion. The first religions started as just superstitions, like eating the heart of your hunt makes you stronger. Science and religion have both changed, and neither will ever be 100 percent right, no matter if there is or isn't a god.

Where does the Bible talk about the earth being the center of the Universe? 

The Church (ie: Catholic) have been wrong countless times throughout history.  The Crusades, Witches, believing the earth to be flat, believing the earth to be the center of the universe, oppression of peoples around the world, etc, etc.  But each of those wrongs were not created by referencing the Bible.  They originated from power-hungry men who came into leadership positions withing the Church.  The only reason that they could get away with most of the wrong-doing is because the actually stifled the general populations ability to read the Bible for themselves.  All reading, teaching and interpretation of the Bible was done by the leaders of the Catholic church.

Read about the origin of Christianity, and the subsequent denominational churches.  Its really interesting.  The Catholic church came about because Christianity became the official religion of Rome.  Constantine became a Christian, but because Government was all he knew, the Churches in Rome became very legalistic and organized... very political.  All subsequent denominations have been attempts to get away from all of that and focus only on the Bible. 

Note: if any of you are Catholic, I mean no disrespect.  Just trying to present the facts as they are.

The Bible itself is accurate.  Original manuscripts have been compared with current versions.  Everything matches.  What other document in history is still EXACTLY the same as it was 4,000+ years ago?  Granted, the New Testament was added to the Bible in about 350AD (can't remember exact date), but even it has been compared with what we have now, and can be verified.  Additionally, ancient historians who had no ties to religion of any kind wrote manuscripts that verify much of the Bible's contents.

Casper, you seem to be making very general statements.  You said that much of the bible is false, but can't make a compelling argument as to why that is.  When I replied to that with some actual facts, you decide to talk about the wrongs of the Church, which are not connected with the teachings of the Bible.  Research.  Know what you are talking about. 
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: RedRumOnE on September 18, 2010, 03:35:00 PM
lol i remember when i first commented on this post :P

(http://i54.tinypic.com/2hfnalj.jpg)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on September 30, 2010, 07:48:36 PM
Google "Zeitgeist" and watch it in its entirety.  Then get back to and we can talk about 'god' and the likes.  I've read the bible in its entirety and I won't discuss this without my conversational counter-parts having the same information.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 01, 2010, 08:21:43 PM
Google "Zeitgeist" and watch it in its entirety.  Then get back to and we can talk about 'god' and the likes.  I've read the bible in its entirety and I won't discuss this without my conversational counter-parts having the same information.
I haven't seen the whole thing, but my older brother told me a lot about it. It brings up some pretty good points, I'm gonna watch it once I find a download
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 02, 2010, 08:16:10 PM
I feel like I've seen it on youtube, but don't quote me.  I've got a copy, if you want.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 03, 2010, 09:21:45 AM
Nah, I'll just google it when I get the time. Haha. My older brother probly has a copy I could borrow if google fails me
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 03, 2010, 12:47:02 PM
Alright, I've decided to post basically all my beliefs. They aren't about how life was created, but more of how it works. Not biologically, but the role of consciousness. Nearly everything I believe about consciousness is from my own thinking, not things I've found elsewhere. I believe that nearly everything has a limited amount of consciousness. People, of course, are conscious. Animals are too, because they can feel pain and think. They are, after all, capable of thought, just not to the same extent as us. Then there's lesser animals, like bees and ants. They think, not even close to our capability or animals' capability, but still have a limited sort of consciousness. Then there's, of course, robots and other sorts of artificial intelligence. They do think: they do it through algorithms and the like, but they operate based on sensory input, just like everything mentioned before. The difference is that they have different drives: they don't care about survival or reproduction. They care about giving the output they were programmed to give. I've never seen any reason to dismiss their consciousness, except for their lack of self awareness. Then again, if we wanted to, we could easily mimic the self awareness of lesser creatures. Anyway, my trouble with consciousness is that there is no clearly defined line. My main belief about consciousness is that everything has it. I believe that it is how our universe is run. It is all run by mathematic equations. Taking in input and spitting out the input: that's how robots are run. I know my beliefs are a bit farfetched at this point, but it makes perfect sense to me. I'm open minded to most things, so please post if you find any issues with my beliefs. I have an entire journal full of things like this, and may consider posting a bit more of them eventually. I had to rephrase it all, because I built all the entries off of others, so you wouldn't have understood it copied and pasted from my journal. Lol.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 03, 2010, 02:03:03 PM
(http://img1.fantasticfiction.co.uk/images/n4/n24128.jpg)

Casper, I love your thinking.  Please, if you haven't already, please read this book.  There is an entire chapter regarding a study that Princeton students conducted about bee's, collective intelligence, and consciousness.  This is a true story, so if you're easily freaked out, I really wouldn't read it at night.  Honestly, if you can't find a cheap copy, I'll send you mine.  I feel the same way.  When I talk to other people like us, who form their own 'religion' per se, you'll find striking similarities.  I was an anthropology major for a long while, though I never did finish that degree.  When you study religion and belief across the globe, you will always find similarities.  People tend to isolate the differences and concentrate their own beliefs regarding these. . .  My advice: find the similarities.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 03, 2010, 02:28:43 PM
I'm defintely checking out that book. Haha. I read a summary of it, and while at first I thought it was just another abduction story, it seems much more than that after reading the while summary. I've never believed aliens abduct people for the same reason I believe that a god wouldn't answer prayers: we just aren't very significant. But, I am, if anything, open minded.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 03, 2010, 02:32:58 PM
Also, sorry for the double post. But the hive consciousness of bees helps demonstrate my beliefs on consciousness. They operate as a single being, yet each have their own thought, too. It works like the neurons in our brain: they do, individually, have consciousness. But, as a group, communicating through pheremones, act as a single entity. It shows how consciousness is based not on a single organisms thought and senses, but as a group of reactions and communications.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 03, 2010, 02:44:09 PM
YOU NAILED IT~!  ;)  you've got to read it!
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 03, 2010, 02:54:08 PM
Haha I definitely will :)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 03, 2010, 08:59:53 PM
Decided to post a bit more of my beliefs:
almost everything unique that I believe is based around consciousness. My outlook on life is no different. reality is merely what you experience. To you, the only thing that truly matters is you. In your subjective reality, your consciousness is all that exists. Basically: do what makes you happy. Not what makes others happy, but what satisfies you. I'm not saying stab everyone in the back, but I'm saying don't worry about others, worry about yourself. If helping others makes you happy, then do it. If using people for personal gain makes you happy, do it. All you know is real is what you experience. The way I see it, the only person that exists is you, because you don't experience what other people do. This is one of few beliefs I have that have been influenced by another source, in this case, being microcelestialism. I feel like i need to say more about this, but it really is a very simple concept. Haha
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 04, 2010, 10:14:40 AM
Decided to post a bit more of my beliefs:
almost everything unique that I believe is based around consciousness. My outlook on life is no different. reality is merely what you experience. To you, the only thing that truly matters is you. In your subjective reality, your consciousness is all that exists. Basically: do what makes you happy. Not what makes others happy, but what satisfies you. I'm not saying stab everyone in the back, but I'm saying don't worry about others, worry about yourself. If helping others makes you happy, then do it. If using people for personal gain makes you happy, do it. All you know is real is what you experience. The way I see it, the only person that exists is you, because you don't experience what other people do. This is one of few beliefs I have that have been influenced by another source, in this case, being microcelestialism. I feel like i need to say more about this, but it really is a very simple concept. Haha

AHahah, Its not that I DONT agree with you, and I don't mean to sound mean, but this is basically Charles Manson's entire ethos!
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 04, 2010, 11:23:56 AM
Lmao! Like, for real? That's wierd... xD I assure you I won't kill anyone :p I'm one of those wierdos that like doing good things for random people, don't worry. Lmao
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 04, 2010, 08:15:38 PM
Lmao! Like, for real? That's wierd... xD I assure you I won't kill anyone :p I'm one of those wierdos that like doing good things for random people, don't worry. Lmao

no i know.. it was just food for thought.  Do what you will with it. Like I said, I don't disagree.  Alot of benevolent people feel the same.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 04, 2010, 09:43:59 PM
Lol yeah. Almost anything can be construed as evil though. It's all in how you see it. Haha
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 05, 2010, 10:10:51 AM
well, cool casper.  Thanks for sharing all that.  It was fun to read. *sip*
Personally, (light your flamethrowers now) I think all this 'divine' talk is a little to whimsical for my brain-buds.  I tend to think the human race as a whole places a lot of importance on themselves, and tend to think that for this reason, there just MUST be something out there driving everything. . .  Sorry, but I think we only think we are special because its our own stupid brains thinking about themselves..  *runs away*
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 05, 2010, 11:54:00 AM
Haha same here. I've always thought we were here by pure coincidence, I've never believed any of the divine stuff... Haha
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 05, 2010, 05:59:30 PM
God is just a word we use to describe something our human minds couldn't possibly ever comprehend. 
Good and evil, though, are human inventions. . .
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKQuaKe on October 05, 2010, 06:16:28 PM
popcorn
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 05, 2010, 06:30:21 PM
God is just a word we use to describe something our human minds couldn't possibly ever comprehend. 
Good and evil, though, are human inventions. . .
I completely agree with the good and evil thing. Without our morals or rules, good and evil would be indistinguishable. But what do you mean about the idea of god? I know there's a lot we cannot possibly comprehend, but what particularly are you referring to?
And quake: lolwhut? :p
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 05, 2010, 06:49:41 PM
Let me see if I can summarize..

If there is a 'reason' there is 'something' rather than 'nothing' and I do mean NOTHING, that reason is called 'god' and cannot be understood by any human intelligence.  This is why I don't bother trying.
To me, it seems stranger that there is 'something' rather than 'nothing at all'.
Keyword: If

Of coarse, there doesn't 'have' to be a reason at all. . .

Does that help?

Ps, you should read my bio in the 'meet the players' section before we continue on..
http://www.1upclan.info/forum/index.php?topic=106.45 (http://www.1upclan.info/forum/index.php?topic=106.45)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 05, 2010, 06:56:31 PM
It might be because I'm tired as hell, so I'm having trouble getting the idea... Do you mean "god" is the reason we even exist? And without this "reason", it would be more likely that nothing would even exist? Not god as in religious views, but just as... Well, the reason? Damn, it's hard to out it into words, I get the trouble you had, lol
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 05, 2010, 07:03:18 PM
It might be because I'm tired as hell, so I'm having trouble getting the idea... Do you mean "god" is the reason we even exist? And without this "reason", it would be more likely that nothing would even exist? Not god as in religious views, but just as... Well, the reason? Damn, it's hard to out it into words, I get the trouble you had, lol

See what I mean? Its difficult to place even the whisper of the general idea into words, let alone see, feel, and understand the real McCoy.  Its just thought, without opinion.  What I meant was 'if' there is a reason, that reason is what some call 'god'.  Thats an 'if/then' argument in the literal/logical sense of an 'argument'.  One can also argue then 'if there is no reason, there is no god' and so on..   Just logical dilemmas I care not to trouble myself with. . . But since the discussion was open, I choose 'if there is a reason, that reason is god'.  It begs an answer I do not need. (nor care for) 
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKQuaKe on October 05, 2010, 07:10:38 PM
I laughed very hard at your sig gemma. hilarious. (the it was this deep one)

popcorn means im just sitting back and enjoying the convo
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 05, 2010, 07:20:36 PM
@quake: ahh, I see. I've never heard anyone say it like that lol.

And gemma: that's basically how I feel. The logical dillemma thing. And I've never thought of god in that way. And the thought that existence itself is... Almost out of place, I guess. I've never thought of that, and I've questioned reality quite a bit. I still don't think that we have a conscious being shaping our universe, but that "reason" for existence has definitely made me think. I'm not going to suddenly devote myself to god or anything, but it certainly opens up my mind...
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 05, 2010, 07:33:55 PM
Just for the record though, I never said there 'is' a reason.  Its just.. well.. popcorn. .
I'd be careful with that consciousness thing though..  Neither science nor religion can define it, but it defines you
It literally could be that simple.  What if you could move things with your mind?  What if you could build things with it?  There have literally been documented cases of people moving objects with their minds, or 'consciousness'.

So... What if there were a consciousness 10million x the size of the sun?  What then would it be capable of?  What would it's dreams be like?  My father told me once 'if you can fathom it, it is possible'.  Even young children wonder 'could this all be a dream? Could reality literally be a figment of my imagination?'  My question to you now is:
Could we all be a dream? A literal figment of 'its' aka 'the reason's' imagination?

Well.. Could we?  Just a little more popcorn for you..
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 05, 2010, 07:34:26 PM
I laughed very hard at your sig gemma. hilarious. (the it was this deep one)

popcorn means im just sitting back and enjoying the convo

oh and thanks. 
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 05, 2010, 07:50:02 PM
My problem with the consciousness 100000 times the size of our sun is that, if consciousness is truly just the interaction between forces and particles, not all consciousness is self aware. In fact, very, very little would be. They would work like a computer: taking in forces, spitting out the according movements and reactions. We can only think because of our brains. Unless there is a physical structure calculating and moving throughout the universe, as big as the universe, I don't believe there could be a god, in the way most people see god. And also: I know you didn't say there is a reason, but there was nothing to say about the alternative. It's always more interesting to go with the idea that requires more thinking, not ending the thoughts. Which, is why I assume all this is real. If this isn't real, if we are just a dream, or in a dream, then what else is there to wonder about? It's much better, imo, to assume this is all real. It's like a maze: why purposely head toward the dead end when there's so much more to explore?
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 05, 2010, 09:19:34 PM
My problem with the consciousness 100000 times the size of our sun is that, if consciousness is truly just the interaction between forces and particles, not all consciousness is self aware. In fact, very, very little would be. They would work like a computer: taking in forces, spitting out the according movements and reactions. We can only think because of our brains. Unless there is a physical structure calculating and moving throughout the universe, as big as the universe, I don't believe there could be a god, in the way most people see god. And also: I know you didn't say there is a reason, but there was nothing to say about the alternative. It's always more interesting to go with the idea that requires more thinking, not ending the thoughts. Which, is why I assume all this is real. If this isn't real, if we are just a dream, or in a dream, then what else is there to wonder about? It's much better, imo, to assume this is all real. It's like a maze: why purposely head toward the dead end when there's so much more to explore?

Well, thats not really what I was saying.  I didn't mean that this isn't real, and by real, I mean physical.  What I meant is that if a 'being' as small as us can move objects, what could a massive 'being' do?  I didn't really mean a literal 'dream', more, a manifestation of its own will.  The universe, and by 'universe' i mean 'time', expands as the giant sleeps. . .   Its a fun little corner of the maze, thats all.  Again, its not necessarily my opinion that this is the case, its just fun to explore the idea.  Again, I won't really discuss my actual opinions until I talk with someone that has the same information that I do.  Wars are fought that way, and people die for this reason. 

Something I've been thinking about more than 'god' lately is 'nothing'.  And by nothing, I mean the lack of 'all'.
No matter, no time, no space... Nothing.  I have a small tattoo to remind me of this often, and I find myself getting even more confused 12 years after I marked myself with it.

I read this article in science magazine regarding 'anti-matter'.  Steven Hawking seems to think that in the beginning there was this great collision of matter and anti-matter.  I don't have a problem talking about my opinions regarding this, because it does not contend with anyone's beliefs regarding 'god':

My problem with the entire concept of 'anti matter' is that it 'isn't' at all.  Its not 'something' in the sense that we think of 'things', in fact, it must be quite the opposite.  Its the lack of all things.  'It', is 'nothing'.   Try to imagine 'nothing' and out of nothing, comes the universe.  Through a pinhole, time, matter, and 'all' comes roaring, expanding, destroying nothing in its path.  But where did it come from? I think, Casper, it came from the same place its going:  The center of the universe.  Try to bear with me on this:

Try to imagine the universe having two parts: one expanding, one collapsing. As one expands, from the pinhole, the other is collapsing into the same pinhole.  Try to imagine it looking something like an hour-glass.  Its like taking a beach-ball, letting some air out, and twisting it in the middle.  As you squeeze one side of it, the air moves into the other side, and visa versa.  We already know that time is contingent upon gravity, which is contingent upon matter and mass.  So then, what happens when the entire universe has finally been pressed through the pinhole?
Well, 'nothing' is left.  Nothing has infinite time and gravity.  The entire universe on the other side of the *ahem* beach-ball, is sucked back through the pinhole, and the process repeats itself. . . Forever.

This means, yes, for if only a blink of an eye, the entire universe could actually be the size of a (beach-ball?) as it is "Big Banging" outward again.  Thats just fun.

I told my wife this one night and she asked me 'But Evan, what If you could stand outside of the beach-ball and watch the universe expand/contract.  'where' exactly would you be standing? After thinking about it for a long time, my answer is finally this: 'nowhere'.  Moreover, IF this was possible, you wouldn't be able to 'see' the universe at all. It doesn't exist in your time.  You are, in a hypothetical sense, your very own universe at that moment.  You can't see through what does not exist. 

Okay, assuming you're still reading, I have another fun bucket-o-popcorn:  If the universe is repeating itself over and over again (and please, get the hour-glass picture out of your head now, it doesn't actually look like that)
Does it:
1. Repeat itself exactly as it did before? or
2. Change.  Every time, a new and different universe.

Both are fun to explore.  for option 1, its fun to think that we will exist, are existing, and have existed, an infinite number of 'times'.  (this also helps explain de ja vu!)
For option 2, well, thats just one giant popcorn-ball, baby.



Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 05, 2010, 09:22:58 PM
My problem with the consciousness 100000 times the size of our sun is that, if consciousness is truly just the interaction between forces and particles, not all consciousness is self aware. In fact, very, very little would be. They would work like a computer: taking in forces, spitting out the according movements and reactions. We can only think because of our brains. Unless there is a physical structure calculating and moving throughout the universe, as big as the universe, I don't believe there could be a god, in the way most people see god. And also: I know you didn't say there is a reason, but there was nothing to say about the alternative. It's always more interesting to go with the idea that requires more thinking, not ending the thoughts. Which, is why I assume all this is real. If this isn't real, if we are just a dream, or in a dream, then what else is there to wonder about? It's much better, imo, to assume this is all real. It's like a maze: why purposely head toward the dead end when there's so much more to explore?

Well, thats not really what I was saying.  I didn't mean that this isn't real, and by real, I mean physical.  What I meant is that if a 'being' as small as us can move objects, what could a massive 'being' do?  I didn't really mean a literal 'dream', more, a manifestation of its own will.  The universe, and by 'universe' i mean 'time', expands as the giant sleeps. . .   Its a fun little corner of the maze, thats all.  Again, its not necessarily my opinion that this is the case, its just fun to explore the idea.  Again, I won't really discuss my actual opinions until I talk with someone that has the same information that I do.  Wars are fought that way, and people die for this reason. 

Something I've been thinking about more than 'god' lately is 'nothing'.  And by nothing, I mean the lack of 'all'.
No matter, no time, no space... Nothing.  I have a small tattoo to remind me of this often, and I find myself getting even more confused 12 years after I marked myself with it.

I read this article in science magazine regarding 'anti-matter'.  Steven Hawking seems to think that in the beginning there was this great collision of matter and anti-matter.  I don't have a problem talking about my opinions regarding this, because it does not contend with anyone's beliefs regarding 'god':

My problem with the entire concept of 'anti matter' is that it 'isn't' at all.  Its not 'something' in the sense that we think of 'things', in fact, it must be quite the opposite.  Its the lack of all things.  'It', is 'nothing'.   Try to imagine 'nothing' and out of nothing, comes the universe.  Through a pinhole, time, matter, and 'all' comes roaring, expanding, destroying nothing in its path.  But where did it come from? I think, Casper, it came from the same place its going:  The center of the universe.  Try to bear with me on this:

Try to imagine the universe having two parts: one expanding, one collapsing. As one expands, from the pinhole, the other is collapsing into the same pinhole.  Try to imagine it looking something like an hour-glass.  Its like taking a beach-ball, letting some air out, and twisting it in the middle.  As you squeeze one side of it, the air moves into the other side, and visa versa.  We already know that time is contingent upon gravity, which is contingent upon matter and mass.  So then, what happens when the entire universe has finally been pressed through the pinhole?
Well, 'nothing' is left.  Nothing has infinite time and gravity.  The entire universe on the other side of the *ahem* beach-ball, is sucked back through the pinhole, and the process repeats itself. . . Forever.

This means, yes, for if only a blink of an eye, the entire universe could actually be the size of a (beach-ball?) as it is "Big Banging" outward again.  Thats just fun.

I told my wife this one night and she asked me 'But Evan, what If you could stand outside of the beach-ball and watch the universe expand/contract.  'where' exactly would you be standing? After thinking about it for a long time, my answer is finally this: 'nowhere'.  Moreover, IF this was possible, you wouldn't be able to 'see' the universe at all. It doesn't exist in your time.  You are, in a hypothetical sense, your very own universe at that moment.  You can't see through what does not exist. 

Okay, assuming you're still reading, I have another fun bucket-o-popcorn:  If the universe is repeating itself over and over again (and please, get the hour-glass picture out of your head now, it doesn't actually look like that)
Does it:
1. Repeat itself exactly as it did before? or
2. Change.  Every time, a new and different universe.

Both are fun to explore.  for option 1, its fun to think that we will exist, are existing, and have existed, an infinite number of 'times'.  (this also helps explain de ja vu!)
For option 2, well, thats just one giant popcorn-ball, baby.

oh & ps, I don't like stephen hawking.  I think mostly he's put on a pedestal because he is disabled, and not nearly as intelligent as he would like to think that he is.  Its like everyone just feels sorry for him, so they let him think that.  Mostly, I think he just likes to **** with people's minds, and there are much smarter people than him.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 05, 2010, 10:19:56 PM
That's one of the most interesting thoughts I've ever heard. Although, here's another fun little twist in the maze: how can we define the edge of the universe? If space is nothingness, (I know u didn't say this, but many people do), then how can the universe have boundaries at all? Can we just not move past the edge of the universe? If space didn't have an edge, then that would mean half of the things we think about the universe can't be true. I'll have much better thoughts tommorrow, I'm too tired to think straight... Lol
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 05, 2010, 10:41:15 PM
That's one of the most interesting thoughts I've ever heard. Although, here's another fun little twist in the maze: how can we define the edge of the universe? If space is nothingness, (I know u didn't say this, but many people do), then how can the universe have boundaries at all? Can we just not move past the edge of the universe? If space didn't have an edge, then that would mean half of the things we think about the universe can't be true. I'll have much better thoughts tommorrow, I'm too tired to think straight... Lol

No, i mean quite the opposite.  The universe DOES have an edge.  Space is not 'nothing' because even in space, time passes.  No matter where you are, or how far out you go, you are still under the influence of gravity, and time will still past, hence, YOU still exist.  Now, if you could fly a ship to the edge of the universe, here is what would happen:
time would slow down, slower, and slower, the closer you got, until you actually hit the 'event horizon' and basically, time would stop/seize to exist.  Fly a little further, which is clearly impossible, and 'you' would seize to exist in the most literal sense you can imagine.  You and your ship would literally be your very own universe. Stuck 'there', forever. Time would never pass, and the universe wouldn't exist in 'your' new universe. Where is 'there'? you might ask? Nowhere. 'where' is home? it doesn't exist for you anymore.  Which way to fly go get back? You can't fly through what doesn't exist.  What would you do? You can't 'do' anything, because 'doing' takes time, and you don't have it.  'you' would exist, but only to you. See what I'm getting at?  Thats one theory, and its almost the same theory I have regarding death.

The other, and in my personal opinion, if you fly a strait line across the universe 999,999,999x the speed of light, you would eventually just end up in the same place you started, but about a trillion years would have passed.  Nice trip, right? 

I don't mean to sound condescending, but you're not grasping the concept of 'nothing' yet.  The difference between space and 'nothing' is 'direction/dimension' and time. .  I'm not saying that I have by any means at all either.  I think its a long journey, and finally, when we die, we will say to ourselves 'I get it' .. . . . forever. 
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 06, 2010, 07:31:02 AM
Oh, I think i get it... Sorry, I can't get the idea that space is nothing out of my head, lol. It's what I think of. I'd think there has to be a physical difference between space and nothing. I still like to believe that the universe is infinite, though. It's much simpler... Much more... Primal, I guess. Everything about the universe is, in my experience, deceptively simple in it's nature. Most parts of the universe aren't as complex as earth. The most complicates thing that's commonly found is stars, going through nuclear fusion. Also, a lot of ongoing patterns seem to exist. One is that everything cannot be destroyed, only recycled. Which is the only reason I've ever actually considered an afterlife of some sort. Another pattern is infinity: the only thing we know for sure is limited is the speed of light, for some unknown reason. The highest number is infinity, and since mathematics run the universe, that alone means quite a bit. There was a few more occurences of infinity, but I can't seem to remember them atm. If the universe was infinite, then that would open up a big fun part of the maze. I.e., by the laws of probability, an exact copy of our planet would exist elsewhere. Isn't that just incredible to think about?
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 06, 2010, 08:57:59 AM
Whatever floats your boat I guess, casp.

For me, 'nothing' is easier than infinite.  Nothing is also more interesting than infinite.  The universe has a boundary, but that doesn't mean that there could be an infinite number of universes. .   Anyways, its a little early for this.

ttyl.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: CaptainTrips on October 06, 2010, 03:58:34 PM
  Space is not 'nothing' because even in space, time passes.  No matter where you are, or how far out you go, you are still under the influence of gravity


Quick question... what about like the time before the big bang... when everything was probably in a state of nothing did time pass?

Just curious :)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 06, 2010, 04:10:35 PM
  Space is not 'nothing' because even in space, time passes.  No matter where you are, or how far out you go, you are still under the influence of gravity


Quick question... what about like the time before the big bang... when everything was probably in a state of nothing did time pass?

Just curious :)
hmm... that thought broke the universe :0 if time was not moving and everything was nothing, then how would the big bang have happened? even if it took .00000000000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000001x10-999999999 billionth of a second, it still took time. so if time was "frozen", then how could it have happened?
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: CaptainTrips on October 06, 2010, 04:12:20 PM
  Space is not 'nothing' because even in space, time passes.  No matter where you are, or how far out you go, you are still under the influence of gravity


Quick question... what about like the time before the big bang... when everything was probably in a state of nothing did time pass?

Just curious :)
hmm... that thought broke the universe :0 if time was not moving and everything was nothing, then how would the big bang have happened? even if it took .00000000000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000001x10-999999999 billionth of a second, it still took time. so if time was "frozen", then how could it have happened?

How can nothing turn into something?
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 06, 2010, 04:16:33 PM
  Space is not 'nothing' because even in space, time passes.  No matter where you are, or how far out you go, you are still under the influence of gravity


Quick question... what about like the time before the big bang... when everything was probably in a state of nothing did time pass?

Just curious :)
hmm... that thought broke the universe :0 if time was not moving and everything was nothing, then how would the big bang have happened? even if it took .00000000000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000000001x10-999999999 billionth of a second, it still took time. so if time was "frozen", then how could it have happened?

How can nothing turn into something?
Damn. Just realized before the big bang, there was an infinitely small particle that was space... oopsies. lol
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: CaptainTrips on October 06, 2010, 04:17:30 PM
and how did that little particle come into existence.... hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm?
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 06, 2010, 04:24:12 PM
Probably always has existed. lol. or maybe its like gemmas idea: its just that little bit poking out if the pinhole :D
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: CaptainTrips on October 06, 2010, 04:37:57 PM
so it's always been there? and it just popped out of nothing?
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 06, 2010, 04:40:54 PM
It cant be both, it either popped out of nothing OR always existed. lol. :p
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: CaptainTrips on October 06, 2010, 04:42:37 PM
nope... it has to begin somehow.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 06, 2010, 04:55:34 PM
nope... it has to begin somehow.
and why is that?
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: CaptainTrips on October 06, 2010, 05:01:28 PM
Then the universe would have no real beginning. Therefor you are saying that the universe is eternal and that theory is highly flawed. Not saying that any other theory is any less flawed.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 06, 2010, 05:04:17 PM
Almost every theory has major flaws. but why does the universe need a beginning?ive never heard any eveidence that the universe is expanding, besides the whole thing about the doppler effect. although, if there was a big enough explosion, then we would all be moving away from the galaxies around us. but that would take a hell of a huge force :0 lol
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: CaptainTrips on October 06, 2010, 05:09:00 PM
I never said it has to have a beginning. It just seems more logical in my opinion.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 06, 2010, 05:13:07 PM
I never said it has to have a beginning. It just seems more logical in my opinion.
Thats just standard human thinking. We like things to be organized. We like there to be a begining, middle, and end, and to chronicle everything that happens
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: CaptainTrips on October 06, 2010, 05:16:46 PM
I agree..
but understanding eternity can be hard.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 06, 2010, 05:18:06 PM
Yeah, it is hard to grasp sometimes. but, that doesnt make it less likely. it just gives you more popcorn :)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: CaptainTrips on October 06, 2010, 05:19:32 PM
I like that idea. <3 popcorn
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 06, 2010, 05:55:47 PM
  Space is not 'nothing' because even in space, time passes.  No matter where you are, or how far out you go, you are still under the influence of gravity


Quick question... what about like the time before the big bang... when everything was probably in a state of nothing did time pass?

Just curious :)

time, and all OTHER dimentions, did not exist.  This is nothing. Now you're getting it.  ;) Theres problems with your question though.  First of all, there was no 'time' or 'before' the big bang.  I know thats hard. Don't try too hard.
Also, nothing is not 'everything', and therefor 'when' is out of context completely.  I know, I know its really difficult.

Trip out on this captain. Just a weird popcorn kernal I found in my brain here a while back.  Did you know that the amount of energy the human body/mind uses does not equal what we put into it?  That there is some sort of little power-plant that drives us each day?  Did you know that the human body weighs approximately 12 grams less post mortem? Nobody knows the reason behind either of these phenomena. 

What if our...*ahem* 'ghost' (for simplicity's sake) is like a little fusion reactor. Much like a star, its our little 'motor' if you will? So, when we die, is it possible that it collapses much like a star does? Where does it go? Think about the beach-ball thing again.. Theres only one direction it can go! 
Think about it. Chew slowly.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 06, 2010, 06:01:17 PM
Okay, this is the part where I drop out of the conversation.  Captain asked 'how can something come from nothing?'
No idea, my friend.  I've no idea, no opinion, and frankly, I'm just not smart enough to even begin to answer that.

I will say this:

This takes us back to the earlier part of Mine and Casper's talk about 'the reason'.  Remember when I said our human intellect cannot comprehend such things?  Don't break a blood vessel guys.

-Gemma, out.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 06, 2010, 06:04:50 PM
-Gemma, out.
NOES!!!! need... more... popcorn...
:)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 06, 2010, 06:13:29 PM
haha, i modified the post i made in regard to captains question regarding the big bang and such. (which, btw, I don't even subscribe to the big-bang)

Read the part where I was talking about 'our little power-plant' and get back to me.  Don't get the kernels stuck in your teeth!
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: CaptainTrips on October 06, 2010, 06:16:54 PM
Thank you kind sir...

Let us get into philosophy?

Is the person I am now the same person I was last year?

Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 06, 2010, 06:51:30 PM
Thank you kind sir...

Let us get into philosophy?

Is the person I am now the same person I was last year?

technically, not completely.  I forget the actual statistic, but its something like every 4 years, every single cell in your body has been destroyed, and subsequently replaced with a new one..  Although, I'm not really into this kind of thinking..  I'm more of the 'all my mistakes and scars make me what I am' kinda guy. . .
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 08, 2010, 09:24:16 PM
Thank you kind sir...

Let us get into philosophy?

Is the person I am now the same person I was last year?

technically, not completely.  I forget the actual statistic, but its something like every 4 years, every single cell in your body has been destroyed, and subsequently replaced with a new one..  Although, I'm not really into this kind of thinking..  I'm more of the 'all my mistakes and scars make me what I am' kinda guy. . .
Well, it doesnt really matter if your the same person, when you think about it. We are made by a combination of memories and instinct. Hell, if someone could alter our memories, they could mold us to however they like. Actually, i just had a realization. If consciousness does indeed come from interactions... then every second, we probably have a different "consciousness". our memories create the illusion that we reamin exactly the same, when we are actually changing constantly.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: CaptainTrips on October 09, 2010, 09:55:18 AM
even though you have a different consciousness aren't you still yourself?

I remember hearing someone say.

Quote
The you who you will die as, is the only you who ever was.


Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 09, 2010, 10:38:59 AM
even though you have a different consciousness aren't you still yourself?

I remember hearing someone say.

Quote
The you who you will die as, is the only you who ever was.
Your memories create the illusion of constant consciousness. Your mind could have been just placed into your body, but if your memories are those of your body, then you would think you always occupied your body
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: serialman on October 18, 2010, 12:51:25 AM
Personally, i believe in darwinism. God is only something that the human mind has created. Dont jump all over me though, i believe that there is some sort of higher being, some stuff just cant be explained by science. But i also believe that the big-bang isnt the best theory out there. Another thought, if it doesnt make sense for the universe to be created from absolutely nothing, then how does it make sense that God just happens to be here to make a planet? Shouldnt something have happened to make Him?
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKMaddog on October 18, 2010, 02:08:53 AM
Personally, i believe in darwinism. God is only something that the human mind has created. Dont jump all over me though, i believe that there is some sort of higher being, some stuff just cant be explained by science. But i also believe that the big-bang isnt the best theory out there. Another thought, if it doesnt make sense for the universe to be created from absolutely nothing, then how does it make sense that God just happens to be here to make a planet? Shouldnt something have happened to make Him?

Darwin believed in God, and discredited his own theory.  :)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 18, 2010, 11:08:22 AM
Personally, i believe in darwinism. God is only something that the human mind has created. Dont jump all over me though, i believe that there is some sort of higher being, some stuff just cant be explained by science. But i also believe that the big-bang isnt the best theory out there. Another thought, if it doesnt make sense for the universe to be created from absolutely nothing, then how does it make sense that God just happens to be here to make a planet? Shouldnt something have happened to make Him?

Darwin believed in God, and discredited his own theory.  :)

Also, here we go with that 'him' thing again. 
Basic prinicipals of evolution don't have to discredit Christianity at all.  Christianity has more to do with Jesus than god anyways.  Frankly, the bible shouldn't be interpreted by 'normal' people at all, since it was transcribed from hebrew and arabic, to latin, and subsequently butchered by the roman catholic church, only to end up on our plates some 1200 years later for 'normal' people to derive 'facts' regarding its passages, which, ironically have more to do with his disciples than he himself? [Jesus] I think not. . .  In my own right, I am a Christian, because I believe in Christ.  (btw, what year is it?)

This doesn't make me a creationist either.  See, I think this kind of 'band-wagoning' is, [next to over-population]
the greatest problem that man faces.  At some point, people have lost the ability to think for themselves, and to trust in their hearts.
In regard to 'what came before god' and all this voodoo, I refer to Revelations 1:8:

'I am alpha and Omega.  I am the beginning, and the end' saith the Lord God, he who is, and who was, and who is to come, the Almighty.

See, its all in interpretation.  One must understand that this wasn't written in English, nor in Latin.  There wasn't babelfish.com back then to transcribe it either.  It was interpreted, understood, and then transcribed.  Terms like 'he' 'she' 'who' 'I' and even 'said' or 'saith' need be understood with a grain of salt.   i.e. think for yourself.

Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 18, 2010, 11:11:00 AM
Dammit.  I told myself I wasn't going to post anything regarding my own beliefs..  Aw well.. Start your flame-throwers I guess. . .  :yawn:
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: serialman on October 18, 2010, 08:06:45 PM
Ok, so i got pretty much shredded up there. Lol i need more facts on this subject to really make a good opinion since im a little ignorant, dont i? Haha ok, im fine with that  :P
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Pyrite[1up] on October 18, 2010, 08:29:42 PM
Frankly, the bible shouldn't be interpreted by 'normal' people at all, since it was transcribed from hebrew and arabic, to latin, and subsequently butchered by the roman catholic church, only to end up on our plates some 1200 years later for 'normal' people to derive 'facts' regarding its passages, which, ironically have more to do with his disciples than he himself?

Actually it is translated not transcribed, from Hebrew, and Aramaic (not Arabic), and finally Greek as a set, into each language. A common misconception is that the Bible was translated from one language to another and from that language to another, on down the line. It is not. Each translation is translated from the original Hebrew, Aramaic and Greek. For example, the New American Standard is not a translation of the New King James. Secondly, the Bible should be interpreted by "normal" people, as it was written for man to understand god. Why would god give man a cryptic message that only a few can understand? It is quite clear since the protestant reformation that it is god's will for each human to know god personally. Granted, several thousand years did go by while the law, that is the Pentateuch (first 5 books of the bible) were told orally from generation to generation rather than in writing before the first written accounts appear on stone tablets in cuneiform writing. Although since Jesus walked the earth some thousand years or more after, I think he would have pointed out any differences. Jesus' disciples quotes verses from the Torah in Greek many thousand years later, but appear to have quoted them perfectly as we can see from the dead sea scrolls discovered just this last century.

One last thing, Bibles were "transcribed", but only before Gutenberg invented the printing press :)

Heh, but what do I care, I don't believe any of that bull**** anyway :)
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 18, 2010, 08:41:54 PM
Ok, so i got pretty much shredded up there. Lol i need more facts on this subject to really make a good opinion since im a little ignorant, dont i? Haha ok, im fine with that  :P

Read what pyrite said.  Its a lot more accurate than what I posted.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 18, 2010, 08:51:24 PM
Also, pyrite, anyone ever tell you you're too smart for your own good?
Still, we can agree to disagree on the 'normal' people thing. . .  Just as one shouldn't try to understand the writings of
Nietzsche without either understanding it in its original German, or with the aid of a 'not-normal' person such as yourself. i.e. take an entire class dedicated to one single publication. . .   At any rate, I couldn't possibly care any less about this voodoo.. I shouldn't have said anything at all.  At least I learned something new today though! *dusts feathers*
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 18, 2010, 09:00:03 PM
Ok, so i got pretty much shredded up there. Lol i need more facts on this subject to really make a good opinion since im a little ignorant, dont i? Haha ok, im fine with that  :P

Don't worry about it, this thread is kinda a dead-horse anyways.  I'm still dusting my feathers from pyrite's onslaught..
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 18, 2010, 09:36:34 PM
The thought I've always had is that it should be easier to believe in god. I'm a good person: I don't cheat, steal, hurt people, and I even try to hold back on things like sex. (for personal reasons, none religious) I am just the type of person that always needs to see proof of something. It's how I've always been. I've just always been annoyed, even offended at times, by people that day I'll burn in hell because of that. They seem to always look down on me because I can't follow something I don't believe. I've been raised Christian, and several times, prayed for help during difficult times. It was when I was younger, and hadn't really thought for myself very much. Things never got better. I had to work and work to make things even slightly better. I completely respect all religions that encourage courtesy and kindness, they are a great thing to be a part of. However, this respect is partly keeping me away from church. I'd feel guilty, in a way.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKMaddog on October 18, 2010, 10:44:04 PM
Pyrite, you nailed the whole authenticity of the bible issue.  Its incredible really how exactly the newer manuscripts match the originals.  Its also very reassuring to me that most of the current versions of the bible are translated from the original manuscripts, rather than from eachother.  What other book (whether purely religious or historical) can you say that about?

This is an issue that everyone has to research for themselves.  No matter what you believe, there are some undeniable truths (like the accuracy of the bible) that have to be taken into account.  But at the end of the day, its up to each of us to decide whether such truths inspire us to the hope of something more, or merely a respect of its historical significance.

To Casper, I appreciate your struggles with this issue.  I will tell you that from my own Christian faith and my extensive exploration of both the Bible AND the scientific, at this point in my life, it would actually take more faith for me to discredit God, Creation, Christianity, Christ, and all things spiritual than it does for me to affirm it.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 20, 2010, 09:28:50 PM
Does anyone believe in fate here? I just firmly established my ideas on it, if anyone is interested. It's not a total mind**** or anything, it's just sort of a neat thought.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 21, 2010, 06:03:40 PM
Does anyone believe in fate here? I just firmly established my ideas on it, if anyone is interested. It's not a total mind**** or anything, it's just sort of a neat thought.

Never set your ideas in stone.  Its too hard to break when needed.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 22, 2010, 07:23:37 AM
Does anyone believe in fate here? I just firmly established my ideas on it, if anyone is interested. It's not a total mind**** or anything, it's just sort of a neat thought.

Never set your ideas in stone.  Its too hard to break when needed.
Well, ive got a jackhammer :P
as long as there is a reason to disregard my beliefs, i have no problem doing it. plus, this isnt aything that will change anytime soon, unless they make some odd discoveries in quantum physics
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 22, 2010, 07:37:47 AM
here's exactly how it was I'm my journal thingamajig:

Edit: sorry for the odd spacing, It wouldn't post right.

Randomness
There is no such thing as randomness, or even probability in the sense of a
chance of something happening. Randomness is an idea we created to simulate
or predict possibilities easier. Under the same conditions, results will always
repeat themselves. Only a change in conditions will change results, sometimes
even by adding a single molecule. Even on computers, randomness is faked.
In all computer generated random numbers, they decide the number based on
a number somewhere else, normally the date and time. This means everything
is already predetermined. Not planned by a deity of some sort, but by the
conditions of the universe. While we do have a choice in what we do, the chemicals
and charges in our brain are making us make that decision. As far from "scientific"
as the idea of fate and predetermined actions are, they are true, based purely on science.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on October 22, 2010, 10:22:54 AM
Okay.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on October 22, 2010, 01:56:26 PM
What a well thought out, articulated, and intriguing response :D
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Poe on October 27, 2010, 03:45:32 PM
The thought I've always had is that it should be easier to believe in god. I'm a good person: I don't cheat, steal, hurt people, and I even try to hold back on things like sex. (for personal reasons, none religious) I am just the type of person that always needs to see proof of something. It's how I've always been. I've just always been annoyed, even offended at times, by people that day I'll burn in hell because of that. They seem to always look down on me because I can't follow something I don't believe. I've been raised Christian, and several times, prayed for help during difficult times. It was when I was younger, and hadn't really thought for myself very much. Things never got better. I had to work and work to make things even slightly better. I completely respect all religions that encourage courtesy and kindness, they are a great thing to be a part of. However, this respect is partly keeping me away from church. I'd feel guilty, in a way.

I see we're very similar! Raised Christian, difficult times, staying away from church now, need proof.
When it comes to the Christian faith there can be NO proof. I don't think anyone will ever be able to definitely say that there "is" or there "is not" a God. At the end there are still questions.
I'm more of a science person (Chemistry, the medical field, physics) but I do believe in God. Not because of any proof of existence but more because their is no proof.
One of the main parts of Christianity is faith. In the Bible it says, "Now faith is being sure of what we hope for and certain of what we do not see." If anyone finds a way to prove God I will stop believing. At least, scientifically and logically. Part of God is believing when you shouldn't.
So, I don't look for proof. There isn't any. There can't be for "faith" to make sense.
I just look at the "coincidence's" and "miracles"  of life. And love. The greatest love and joy I've ever felt in my life (including my many drug trips during high school :P) have all been at church retreats. Some may say it's brain washing but I've also felt that alone, in my closet, praying. Placebo effect, insanity, denial of the truth? I don't think so.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKQuaKe on October 27, 2010, 04:33:34 PM
Poe's wacky views are her own and not necessarily those of any other SnK. Thank you.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Poe on October 27, 2010, 10:15:02 PM
Poe's wacky views are her own and not necessarily those of any other SnK. Thank you.

Haha. Hence, me saying "I" and not "We SnK's".
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKQuaKe on October 28, 2010, 12:53:20 PM
I see intelligent design. It is very complex and sustains itself. Think about how long it would take to as a human (Intelligent) vs (Nothing) to start from scratch, and draw out the plans for this world, every living and non living thing... You don't write dog on the piece of paper, you start with matter, atoms etc, then on to genetic code.. And you do it for every living thing on this planet... You plan out reproduction and how its going to work.. Every law, and create that law...

We still don't understand jack **** about the universe, Or earth for that matter, or the human brain. Its going to take a long time, Using alot of intelligence and resources nothing didnt have at its disposal, to figure it out.

For me.. it would take a trillion years and alot of beta testing to get it right.. And im to believe it happened without intelligence and in a given time frame "they" constantly add on to when they realize it can't work
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: SnKMaddog on October 28, 2010, 10:07:03 PM
Poe, I've seen so much evidence that it would actually take MORE faith for me to believe that there is no God and that we all evolved from nothing than to believe that God is real, that he cares for me, and that he created life as we know it. 

Granted, everyone has had their own experiences, but there was a period in my life where I literally dedicated years to examining the scientific aspects of this issue.  Macro evolution simply does not exist.  Every recent scientific discovery in favor of the Darwinian theory has been either been manipulated after the fact or has been "discovered" using highly unreliable methods (radio-carbon dating anyone?).  And the scientific aspect doesn't even begin to scratch the surface of reality!  The spiritual side of things is quite incredible in it of itself. 
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Poe on October 29, 2010, 12:45:54 AM
Poe, I've seen so much evidence that it would actually take MORE faith for me to believe that there is no God and that we all evolved from nothing than to believe that God is real, that he cares for me, and that he created life as we know it. 

Granted, everyone has had their own experiences, but there was a period in my life where I literally dedicated years to examining the scientific aspects of this issue.  Macro evolution simply does not exist.  Every recent scientific discovery in favor of the Darwinian theory has been either been manipulated after the fact or has been "discovered" using highly unreliable methods (radio-carbon dating anyone?).  And the scientific aspect doesn't even begin to scratch the surface of reality!  The spiritual side of things is quite incredible in it of itself.

I'm not saying that there aren't things that point to a God. Part of the reason I believe in God is because logically it makes more sense to me based on chemistry and physics. I'm just saying there will never be a "Yes, this completely proves the existence of God - hands down - no discussion" moment in time. At least I don't believe there will be. I also don't believe there will ever be a moment in time where someone 100% disproves a God, either. Faith plays a huge part in believing.
I would also have to have more faith to believe in no God than a God. I feel the exact same way about what you and Quake said.
We haven't even skimmed the surface of understanding humanity and... well, existence. Science is constantly evolving as time passes by. I doubt we will ever know the entire in's and out's of the human mind or nature or the universe.
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Zoro on November 16, 2010, 02:54:39 AM
Until someone proves aliens are real then I stop believeing any christian beliefs because why would jesus look like us if their are other lifeforms, its just racist
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Gemma on November 17, 2010, 08:04:05 PM
thread lock! QUIck!
Title: Re: God Vs. Something Else
Post by: Casper on November 20, 2010, 10:56:58 PM
Until someone proves aliens are real then I stop believeing any christian beliefs because why would jesus look like us if their are other lifeforms, its just racist
actually, if aliens were proven to exist, I wouldn't have any chance of ever believing in god. That is, unless they believe the exact same things 0.0 lol